Prigg v. Pennsylvania: Slavery, the Supreme Courtroom, and the Ambivalent Structure (Landmark Regulation Circumstances & American Society)
Worth: points - Particulars)
In
Prigg v. Pennsylvania, the Supreme Courtroom thought of extra than simply the destiny of a single slavecatcher. The Courtroom’s majority struck down the free states’ private liberty legal guidelines and reaffirmed federal supremacy in figuring out the procedures for fugitive slave rendition. H. Robert Baker has written the primary and solely book-length therapy of this landmark case that grew to become a pivot level for antebellum politics and regulation some fifteen years earlier than Dred Scott.
Baker addresses the Structure’s ambivalence relating to slavery and freedom. At difficulty have been the attain of slaveholders’ property rights into the free states, the rights of free blacks, and the relative powers of the federal and state governments. By saying federal supremacy in regulating fugitive slave rendition, Prigg v. Pennsylvania was meant to bolster what slaveholders claimed as a constitutional proper. However the resolution solid into doubt the power of free states to outline freedom and to guard their free black populations from kidnapping.
Baker’s eye-opening account raises essential questions concerning the place of slavery within the Structure and the function of the courts in defending it in antebellum America. Greater than that, it demonstrates how judges trend conflicting constitutional interpretations from the identical sources of regulation. In the end, it gives an instructive have a look at how constitutional interpretation that claims to be devoted to impartial authorized rules and a definitive authentic that means is nonetheless freighted with up to date politics and morality.
Prigg v. Pennsylvania is a sobering lesson for these involved with at present’s controversial points, as states search to complement and preempt federal immigration regulation or to overturn
Roe v. Wade.
User Reviews
Be the first to review “Prigg v. Pennsylvania: Slavery, the Supreme Courtroom, and the Ambivalent Structure (Landmark Regulation Circumstances & American Society)”
You must be logged in to post a review.
There are no reviews yet.